Are You There, God? It’s Me, Lenny: Jude Law as The Young Pope Is Damned Near Perfect

Creator, writer and director, Paolo Sorrentino (Youth, This Must Be the Place) calls The Young Pope a “thriller of the soul” and for those of us who’ve seen just two episodes, we have only the context of a gorgeous, provocative and genuinely funny Pope Pius XIII (aka Lenny Belardo). Bare-bottomed and hazy-dreamed, the serial cigarette smoking, Cherry Coke Zero man threatens to banish all would be spiritual thoughts from our brains, and so if by “thriller” he meant that *zing* we feel every time Jude Law’s onscreen, then sign me up for a little bible study. But, I have a feeling this series is going to be a tad bit deeper than initial impressions might have indicated.

Surrounded by lavish scenery (recreated Vatican sets, and gardens in Rome/Viterbo) and the elegant costumery associated with the Catholic church, Law’s Pius, a newly elected 40-something American who — like a certain nupolitician — you might at first be tempted to laugh off and for better reasons, shouldn’t (and can’t) is nearly perfect. Recalling his Gattica perfection in a wholly different way, Law’s every onscreen second commands full attention; his every word leaves audience and whomever he’s speaking with positively salivating. Yes, he’s that damned (whoops!) good. Not a one of the impressive, well-known actors, from James Cromwell as the spurned would-be, to Diane Keaton (doing her Diane Keaton-est to be someone else, but not quite succeeding) as Lenny’s pseudo-mom, Sister Mary, to Javier Cámara’s Monsignor Bernardo Gutierrez  can pull away the camera from Law’s epic performance in the first hours, though two with whom you may be less familiar stand out in shared scenes.

Italy’s Silvio Orlando is a delight, his Cardinal Angelo Voiello’s reactions to the pope’s unusual behavior and declarations; between his facial (in)expressions and genuine incredulity each time he realizes His Holiness is utterly serious cannot be outdone. Not since a Python film have we been so rewarded by such masterful comedic deadpan, and nearly every scene between Orlando and Law, there’s a feeling something could explode (the actors in laughter, or the pope, in irritation).  And, don’t even get me started on that ridiculous, giant mole that will have your brain echoing John Candy’s glorious admonition to Uncle Buck‘s dream-crushing assistant principal every time the Cardinal appears.

Nearly as good in her short episode 2 scenes with Law and Orlando is Belgium’s Cécile de France, who plays the Vatican’s head of marketing. Her Sofia gamely withstands the pope’s terrible taunting, and proves herself more than adept at switching gears and adapting to Lenny’s Law. With a twinkle in her eye and a winking, “Oh, I can handle any pope” attitude, she’s the supremely confident Peggy Olson skating around Vatican City in broad daylight. Speaking of farcical (day)dreams, between Lenny’s cheeky (literally) shower scene, nightmares (he’s actually quite conservative) of his outrageous first address — “We have forgotten to masturbate, to use contraceptives, to get abortions, to celebrate gay marriage, to allow priests to love each other and even to get married … ”

— and the kangaroo scene (yes, there’s a non-dream kangaroo scene), there is pure joy running throughout the papal seriousness.

My only personal experience with the Catholic church is through a few relatives, and while I’ve always been fascinated by the ceremonial pomp — my sister paid (?) to have a reserved seat for foot washing (no pedicure) — I’ve a feeling The Young Pope may take the curiosity to a new level. With Jude Law’s magnificent Lenny/Pope Pius leading the way, this particular heathen is in for the entirety of Paolo Sorrentino’s wickedly sinful (I presume), wonderful ride.

“Enough about me, how is our pope”?
“In seventh heaven”.

The Young Pope airs on HBO Sundays and Mondays (two episodes per week) at 9 pm ET.

Cindy Davis

Cindy Davis

Cindy Davis has been writing about the entertainment industry for ​over seven years, and is the ​Editor-in-Chief at Oohlo, where she muses over television, movies, and pop culture. Previous Senior News Editor at Pajiba, and published at BUST.

You may also like...

  • Freetheklingons

    How did I miss this? I think I knew it was coming then forgot to watch it. I’ll rectify that because…I’m Catholic and I attended re-enactments of Christ’s washing of the apostles’ feet every year during Passion Week (my Dad participated and all my 6 siblings and I were in the procession) as a kid. I was raised uber-Catholic. I love all the pomp and ceremony and the history and wow, I need to watch this. Bonus: Jude Law!! Thanks for the nudge!